Is there any between teachers' unions and the recent teacher misconduct legislation?

....(and other questions....)

Saturday, March 14, 2009

More than academics?

As we have seen both in class and witnessed in our own lives, the roles and responsibilities of schools and educators as a whole have transformed over the years. In the past, schools were responsible for educating students and making sure they had learned the information and skills they would need to succeed in their next level of education, and in the jobs that they would eventually have. Today, schools seem to have a more influential role in making sure that students are learning the content of their academic subjects, but they are also monitoring how students are doing in other areas of their lives; including their mental and physical health. I do not necessarily believe that this is a negative thing, but I do think that it is ultimately the parent’s responsibility to monitor the health and well-being of their children.
It is my belief that one reason this transformation may be occurring is because of the general “breakdown of family” crisis that seems to be happening more and more in our society. Unfortunately, it appears that children are spending a lot of time on their own or being “babysat” by television, video games and the computer. They seem to be missing that parental involvement and attention that is so important throughout childhood and adolescence, and also the physical activity where they just go out and “play”. Parents/guardians who do not necessarily have the time or energy to educate their children on the importance of being healthy are leaving it up to the schools to teach their children how to make healthy choices.
I do believe that certain aspects regarding children’s health are within the jurisdiction of the schools. In regards to school nutrition and obesity, I think that it is the school’s responsibility to serve healthy meals that follow nutritional guidelines. This becomes difficult when you take into account that a large percentage of students are part of the free or reduced lunch programs, because healthy food costs more and is more difficult to keep fresh. In Celeste’s presentation she told us that the government reimbursement does not cover the complete cost of most school lunches, and also “It’s being projected that an increase of 1.5% of families will be in need of school lunch programs” (School Lunch Programs Hit Hard by Food Prices, 7/9/08). Unfortunately, this is something that will only continue to be an issue as the economy continues to suffer.
Schools also have the responsibility to provide ample time, especially for younger students, to get outside for recess. According to the article Children’s Lack of Playtime Seen as Troubling Health, School Issue, Michael Thompson says that “forty percent of elementary schools now offer less than twenty minutes of recess in a six-hour school day”(Education Week, 12/3/08). I agree with Amanda in that there are many things that teachers can do to allow students to move around and be active in the classroom, but they still need to have that “free-time” during recess to have uninterrupted exercise, as well as time to socialize with their peers. This continues to be an important issue, especially when schools are beginning to reduce or cut physical education time in order to provide more time for classroom instruction.
Vaccinations are another health issue that has become more of a school “responsibility” than in the past. As Ria talked about in her presentation, it is difficult to keep track of the immunization records that are not complete. I believe that it is the responsibility of the parent to make sure that their child is ready for school, and this includes having certain immunizations. I think that it is great that she provides the information for parents as to where they can go to get the free vaccines, but do not think that schools need to start providing the actual service of giving the shots.
Overall, I believe that parents have the ultimate responsibility for their children’s health, but schools do have certain obligations that they should adhere to, because students do spend a lot of time in school. Schools should care that they are providing not only for an education in school subjects, but also the whole child.

5 comments:

  1. I absolutely agree with you about the role of parents in raising and educating their children. Did you happen to check out the article, "Facing Up to the Obesity Problem
    How Charter Schooling Might Help" written by Monica Bell? In the very beginning of the article, I found the guidence counselor's remarks to Ms. Bell as a middle school student very interesting. The counselor said, "Monica, you have a single mom. You need to stop gaining weight so she can stop buying you so many new clothes. It’s expensive." Ms. Bell came from a broken home, or a home that was not an "intact family". I believe this break down of the family has caused many of the problems with our young children today. I'm living out this sad situation myself. I have seen one of my boys run to food, and I am almost positive it is because his father left us, and is really not a part of my boys lives. How could this not cause depression in kids? Food absolutely can be a comfort!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Children do spend too much time these days in front of the TV or video games. This lack of physical activity is one of the major causes of childhood obesity. Governor Strickland proposes to have longer school days which would allow even less time for students to be active after school. Maybe we can best serve our children by using that extended day for physical education and non-competitive sports. My son wanted to start playing soccer when he was 11. He was told not to even try, because he would not be able to compete with the kids who had been playing since they were 4 years old. How sad! One similar parent tried to get a non-competitive team started to no avail. “Facing Up to the Obesity Problem” mentions programs for obese children that provide meetings once or twice a week in order to teach them about nutrition and exercise. No amount of talking will stop someone from eating too much or from being a couch potato, but by providing non-judgmental support may help someone make better choices. Education on nutrition is important, and simple things like reading the book Eat This, Not That can really be beneficial. However, it takes opportunities to have fun and to sweat. Schools could provide a safe environment for exercise and games; activities where one does not have to be the most coordinated or fastest runner, but can still be active and have fun.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mary and Jenny, your stories painfully illustrate the complexity of the influence on schools exerted by societal, familial, and personal factors. Add to this the economic realities that Kari highlights (and maybe even throw in some philosophical concerns) and it does seem pretty difficult to know where to start to answer this question...

    ReplyDelete
  4. As a school nurse and as a parent it is becoming more and more alarming as far as the state-of-affairs where it comes to the children. Nurses are considered educators. It is our job to make sure that children remain healthy. How is that possible when you can't get the parents to cooperate? They send their children to school late, knowing they haven't had any breakfast. I get so many children in the clinic before lunch complaining of headaches and stomach aches. I'll have to walk them to the cafeteria to get something to eat and then back to the clinic to eat and lay down. In the mean time they are missing out on their lessons. I've also resorted to having lunch room workers watch certain kids because they like to swap lunches and that obese child ends up with three helpings of burgers or fries while the one who needs more nutrients only eats one container of applesauce for the day.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agreed with your comment that students need “free-time” during recess to have uninterrupted exercise, as well as time to socialize with their peers. Time needs to be provided for students so that they can not only get exercise but so that they can think imaginatively. "It is the natural outpouring of ideas that receive the least attention from those planning curriculum in our nation's schools" states Vivian Gussin Paley." Time needs to provided in schools for free play where students can use their imagination and create stories. Students need to be creative and think outside the box. They can not do this if they are sitting at their desks for 7 hours a day.

    ReplyDelete