I think that increasing choice for parents regarding education can be good. I believe that parents should always have the choice to decide what is best for their child's education. Students should not be forced to stay in a terrible school system if instead they could be sent to a more successful charter school or given vouchers to attend another school. As we discussed in class some charter schools are better than others. I thought our reading on charter schools was interesting when it mentioned that charter schools are becoming increasingly segregated. Half of the charter schools have student populations that are more than 60 percent children of color (Mark F. Bernstein). The Washington-based Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies reported that blacks are 11 percent less likely than whites to be satisfied with their local public schools. I work at a charter where the student population is primarily African American. I think that charter schools are segregated because they are placed in areas where the population has a low socioeconomic status. Parents of children in these school systems want another option of where they can send their child other the public school in their district that is struggling.
I do think that it is a problem that charter schools are using funding from public schools. Charter schools are denying public schools the financial resources they require to address the needs of an increasingly disparate student population (Mark F. Berstein). I do think that it would would be a better idea to use the funding for charter schools to improve the public schools. The funding would help to improve programs such as special education. It also seems to me that because so many students are going to charter schools that there are less teacher openings in the public school system. The public school system will begin to struggle if charter schools continue tend to grow regarding the amount of students they serve. Today charter schools serve more than 1.2 million students.
In the end I think that charter schools are here to stay. I liked the article that I read from Richard Whitmire where New York City schools attracted a few of the most successful charter networks to work with them. "Instead of fighting each other for resources, we ended up trying to figure out how we can deepen the pool and work together to make resources available for all to grow" (John King). Charter schools and public schools do need to stop fighting each other, they need to work together in order to provide the best education possible for each student.

Is there any between teachers' unions and the recent teacher misconduct legislation?
....(and other questions....)
Friday, April 3, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree that the focus shouldn't be who is more effective (althoug obviously important) but rather what is each institution doing that is working for their students. If both charter and public schools could find a way to learn best practices from each other, all students would benefit.
ReplyDeleteI'm inclined to agree with you in that charter schools are here to stay, and we need to find a way for all these different modes of non-parochial/private schools to come together collaboratively and pool their resources. I believe charter schools are gaining in numbers because parents are tired of their child(ren) staying in struggling school systems, not learning, or being bullying or victims of crime. Unfortunately, most of these conditions are more prevalent in areas of lower socioeconomic status. As far as the funding issues...with all the different studies/research and statistics availabe and supportive of charter schools...why can't the government establish a different funding?
ReplyDeleteI agree that the "working together" method is probably going to be the one that will be most successful. There was an article in the Plain Dealer Metro section today titled "Charter schools Propose Network". It discusses how a charter school network is hoping to use $5 million in stimulus money to develop a network for 5,000 kids in Cleveland Public Schools. My understanding is that they are hoping to work with the school system rather then against it.
ReplyDeleteI was shocked to read that 25% of the Cleveland Public school population attends charter schools. Seems that that is sending much of the money "out there" instead of working on improvements.
I do think that one of the problems of working together is that Public Schools are the powerful and ancient dinosaur with well-entrenched and powerful unions that don't want to share and work together. Can't wait to get into the whole Union discussion--they can definitely do as much harm as good! Are they outdated?
ReplyDelete